Governor's Tolerance Commission
Meeting
Kotzebue, Alaska - October 9, 2001
Live on the radio, KOTZ-FM
in Kotzebue.
Kotzebue Borough Assembly Chambers inside the National Guard
Armory
Commission members in attendance:
Rev. Chuck Eddy of Anchorage, Chair
Kelly Brown of Fairbanks, union representative, hosted
Not in My Town forum.
Sen. Bettye Davis of Anchorage, Black Caucus, education
leader
Mara Kimmel of Anchorage, Immigration attorney for Catholic
Social Services
Father Michael Oleksa, cross-cultural trainer from Koliganek
Shari Kochman of Jewish community in Juneau
Lt. Governor Fran Ulmer, ex-officio member
Rep. Mary Kapsner of Bethel, Yupik leader
Marie Greene of Kotzebue, Inupiaq leader, Vice President
and COO of NANA
Thelma Buchholdt of Anchorage, 1st Filipino woman elected
to a legislature in the U.S. served four terms in Alaska
Legislature
Prior to the meeting Commission
members had a tour of the Nikaitchuat Ilisagvait (Inupiaq language
school). Pete Schaeffer, Kotzebue tribal leader, and his daughter
Diane run the school with a small team of staff. There are 18?
Students, and a wait-list. Unlike Bethel's public (charter school)
immersion language program that the Tolerance Commission heard
from last week, this is a private school for kids age 3 to 8,
focusing on Inupiaq language and values. Both programs seem to
be working to increase knowledge of the Native languages. There
are only about 60 residents remaining in the area who speak Inupiaq.
In the late 1800s, traditional Inupiaq education was overshadowed
by Western missionary interests and continued with federal
and state education efforts which punished kids for speaking
in their Native language. The kids gave the Commission a dance
performance in the evening.
From there the Tolerance Commission
toured the Maniilaq Health Center and heard from Eugene Smith,
the Chief Information officer. Kotzebue serves as a regional
health care hub for the outlying coastal villages and communities.
The hospital incorporates 17 acute care beds, and incredible
technology for distance delivery of services through video cams
in the Villages. Through a federal /community partnership Maniilaq
has been successful in offering high-speed internet access at
an affordable price to village residents. The hospital also has
large outpatient areas for dental, medical care, and counseling.
The building was built in 1995 and has beautiful Native art.
Testimony
Northwest Arctic Borough
Mayor Ross Schaeffer
Welcome to Kotzebue,
Overview of Region. Hope you are tolerable of our weather here!
First year anniversary as Mayor. 2nd largest borough in Alaska.
39,000 square miles, 30 miles above the Arctic Circle. Population
7080 -- 90 percent of residents are Inupiaq Eskimos whose ancestors
settled the land over 10,000 years ago. 11 Communities along
Noatak, Kobuk and Kivalina, Selawik, and Ambler Rivers. Region
is based on subsistence. Not as involved as 10,000 years ago
but our people hunt every day. Many of the villagers come to
Kotzebue to hunt sea mammals. Home Rule Charter, highest form
of Government in Alaska. 11 Assembly members, strong Mayor. Largest
regional businesses include NANA Corporation, Maniilaq Association,
NW Arctic Borough School District, Red Dog Mine largest
zinc mine located north of Kotzebue. Two important institutions
UAF Chukchi Campus and Technical Center. Grew up in Kotzebue
and words we sometimes used were Niggerheads and Niggertoes
we didn't even know what that meant. They were words and we were
very naïve. Didn't even see the first black person until
I was 7 years old. The kind of discrimination I see is in the
management of Fish and Game. Institutional. Laws don't protect
our subsistence way of life. Everything that comes out of the
McDowell case, the Katie John case. The use of resources by the
legislature to fight those cases. That makes us feel discriminated
against. So many of our villages will never be able to speak
out, but we suffer without the food. The competition for resources.
Marine Mammal Act. We were told by the state that the Polar Bear
population was under control. Commercial guiding came in and
the polar bears were almost wiped out. 20 years later, in 1990
Finally got my first polar bear. In addition to subsistence rights,
we need some sort of regulation of outfitters. This year we had
one Beaver (larger plane). Next year we'll have at least two
more. Subsistence is an important issue for Alaska Natives.
Willy Goodwin, Chairman,
Regional Elders Council
With guidance and support
from Elders, we must teach our children Inupiag values.
Recently had an Elders conference where 60 elders came in from
villages and joined 20 here in Kotzebue. We reaffirmed the need
to have Elder guidance.
Knowledge of language, knowledge of family tree, sharing, humility,
respect for others, love for children, cooperation, hard work,
respect for elders, respect for nature, avoid conflict, family
roles, humor, spirituality, domestic skills, hunter success,
responsibility to tribe. Subsistence is definitely part of our
lifestyle. The Game Board has not had tolerance. We have had
to go to the feds for help. In the long run, we need the help
from the state to live our lifestyles. Subsistence.
Pete Shaeffer, General Manager,
Kotzebue IRA
I'd like to welcome
you. As I sit here I feel like when I testified before the Board
of Fish and Game. You are a lot nicer. Hope you enjoyed the visit
this morning to the school.
In some political circles, we have about as much chance as changing
minds as a snowball's chance in hell. I see many political leaders
here, though, so I want to share my concerns with you. It's the
people who elect their elected officials, and the thought of
those legislators, representing those people, they make life
so difficult for us in rural Alaska. I'll use the North Slope
as an example, because Senate Bill 36 is making it so hard. Senators
Wilken, Kelly, and those others that take the time to paint a
dishonest picture of what the numbers are, of the people. It's
such a small group of people with intolerance.
American history has this problem.
How could things have been different if one culture embraced
other cultures and welcomed them. Unfortunately, I spent 20 years
laying blame and if I could change those 20 years and turn them
into something more positive, I would. The bonding of people,
the skills of bonding, especially grandparent to grandchild.
I have experienced discrimination in my life. You have to get
over it. It's just plain forgiveness that you have to exercise
and sometimes it's just not that easy to do. I am willing to
take responsibility for my part of it but I think other people
have to take responsibility, too. Religious, cultural upbringing
and who you spend time with. Suggestion: Education to be more
aware of tolerance and issues of understanding. Ignorance and
arrogance make people behave in an unfriendly way.
Charles Mason, CEO, Northwest
Arctic Borough School District
Pete's (Shaeffer) got
a wonderful thing with his school and it's called positive parent
involvement. We don't have that in our school. WE have a village
in crisis here. We are facing a dire shortage of teachers and
administrators. Yet when those teachers come here, they are quite
often run off. This does not know any racial boundaries. Staff
are threatened and nothing is done. Not having a VPSO, not having
a State Trooper, makes things difficult. By the time someone
gets out to the villages to investigate, there's almost a laughable
set of circumstances with juvenile justice. It's not racial intolerance
it's just a problem we need to fix. Schools in crisis comes
from the village in crisis. It's the entire setting.
Shari Kochman -- Why the violence?
Behavior model at home. Spousal abuse. No law in these areas.
Our kids often get angry and we need the resources to help them.
Anger management is something we are trying to do. Terrorist
threats are out there everywhere right now. So many contributing
things. Television, etc.
Are Native teachers treated
differently than non natives? Less than 10 percent of teachers
are native but I still feel isn't racial. Kids have a lack of
respect and know that nothing is going to be done to them. Vandalism
in two classrooms just recently. Damage. One was a Native teacher
classroom. One was non-native. The pay scale has moved so low
that no one is attracted to teaching. Local jobs borough
jobs pay better. Just about anything pays better. Can't
attract folks within the state or outside the state.
Kelly Brown Are you able
to bring in elders to help teach? We do some interaction with
native leaders and have Inupiaq days. but I just have to tell
you that with some of these kids, they are just running wild.
They won't have respect for elders, either.
VPSOs and Constables
would more Natives in those jobs help? We are still faced with
pay and housing, and in the smaller communities how many relatives
you have living there. You can't arrest too many family members
and still feel good about your job. They quit.
Sen. Bettye Davis I can't
believe you'd have a meeting of superintendants where you come
away from that meeting and blame the students. You need to be
coming up with recommendations to the Legislature to make it
work for the students. You mention more safety officers or truant
officers and get the parents involved. What programs do you have
in place and what are the goals? I encourage you to get together
with other superintendants and other groups and get a package
together.
A: The parents who are part
of the problem don't attend our community meetings. We do have
an alternative program in Selawik our largest village.
We are trying to spend 70 percent of each dollar on instruction.
Hiring security officers isn't going to help on our instruction
dollars. We are pursuing options.
Father Oleksa: You mention
Inupiaq days. What is that?
A: Subsistence activities, native arts, part of the values
up to 10 days a year. Done a variety of ways throughout the district.
We have limited bi-lingual component. With the high stakes testing
we are focusing on that curriculum.
Father Oleksa: It seems like
the schools aren't meaningful and relevant to a rural schoolkid's
life. What if they want to stay there in that village. So little
of our curriculum prepares our kids to be productive citizens
of their own community. It's like we are preparing them for elsewhere.
The studies aren't relevant for the kids here.
I agree that may be part of
the problem. We could be better served by teaching kids a vocational
educational curriculum to learn about machinery, equipment.
Bernice Joseph, State of
Alaska Deputy Commissioner, Community and Economic Development
With 15 months left
in the Knowles/Ulmer Administration, our department is focusing
on projects in rural Alaska. A question asked by Father Oleksa
earlier was what percentage of Alaska students do not go on to
college. Our statistics show 70 percent of students statewide
do not go on to college. The State is promoting local hire and
is working on getting more training.
Jobs Summits: Partnerships between University, unions, contractors,
labor sources. Idea is to have the summit three years prior to
planned projects. In the Kotzebue - Northwest area alone, we
are looking at $156 million in projects. We look at anticipated
number and types of jobs. Water and sewer, roads, construction,
airports. How many carpenters and cooks will be needed for those
jobs. One job summit was in Nome. WE had them in St. Mary's,
Unalaska and will have more upcoming. Look at the number of jobs,
the number of skills needed and look at the gaps. DEC, DOT, Dept
of Ed for schools and local school district, unions, laborers.
Pre-bid summits are similar to Job Summits. We had the Denali
training fund, Dept. of Labor and non profits to see what kind
of training programs are available or could be made available.
Koyuyuk has a $7.2 million airport project upcoming. Need to
train more people in health industry, aviation, Dept. of Transportation
jobs. construction. We have to follow up and get middle managers
at DOT to buy into this idea to get more jobs in rural Alaska.
Suggestions: Additional training funds to support and push the
mandatory pre-bid conferences in the communities to prepare for
the future jobs. Oppose Sen. Cowdery's efforts to end force accounting.
Force accounting works in rural Alaska. Make sure local workers
get equal pay to other construction workers. Get more support
for vocational education. Need sub-regional vocational education.
Fran Ulmer: Thank you for explaining
the work that has been done to get jobs in rural Alaska. I'm
just thinking about Father Oleksa's comments of how do we get
students to care about school and jobs. Listening to you makes
me think videos of jobs that are available in rural Alaska
so kids will know what they might want to do. A series of videos
to be shown to students to learn what you talked about today.
What is available to learn construction, and other tools to blend
with a subsistence lifestyle. Help young people. It would probably
need a consortium, and maybe it is something that could be funded
by the Denali Commission.
Bernice: I agree. We need to
start much earlier with kids. If they go to school and want to
be a policemen or firefighter they need to know that drugs and
alcohol can't be part of their life.
Dennis Tiepelman, President,
Maniilaq Association
Using that organization
by way of background, I would like to reflect why we are here.
Racism in all its forms, particularly institutional, exists here.
1973 starting working for this organization. Grew up in Deering,
went to Mt. Edgecumbe, came back here to Kotzebue. We've gone
from a staff of 3 people to 450 people. $50 million budget. Largest
employer in this region outside of Red Dog. We have a $20 million
payroll. I doubt if we have 50 people employed in the villages.
Most employees are here. So we discriminate as well.
NANA and Maniilaq have worked through the good times and bad
times since ANCSA created us. Went to Washington, DC in 1980
because didn't know what Reagan would do with Title 8, Rural
Preference in ANILCA. Flash forward to 2001and some of the similar
attitudes are here and they don't like rural preference. We call
them "rednecks" They have a sporting lifestyle but
don't use the meat. We watch the meat spoil.
History. American Indians and
Alaska Natives have given up a lot. I got this information from
Sen. Inouye of Hawaii. History is based on treaties. All of the
treaties with American Indians and Alaska Natives were violated.
The U.S. has never lived up to its promise. From top down we
have been violated.
Maniilaq. We are a contractor
of federal responsibility for health services. The Alaska Legislature
this year tried to eliminate those contracts to provide services.
We are providing the services with federal grants in lieu of
the state doing it. Now they want to take the funds that we are
using even though we are providing a service. Now that's
institutional racism.
Education. Less than 10 percent
of our teaching staff are Alaska Native. We are failing there.
The statistics of exams bear out that we are failing. The parents,
the community, and what we expect of the school system do not
mesh. Kids don't know what they can be.
Every community around here
is a dry or damp community. But we observe the bootlegging and
the people who bring it in and look the other way. We deal with
the effects of alcohol every day.
People in the villages don't
have a local economy and are upset even with Kotzebue. All the
jobs are here. Even here we have to pay higher wages so people
will take jobs here and then they stay for their "maximum'
three years. We hope they will stay longer, but even here it
is remote villages even more remote. Conflict with villagers
within Maniilaq organization. We are predominantly a village
of friends, yet because I'm not a born-again Christian some people
feel I shouldn't be running this organization.
I have two children. My daughter
just graduated from college. Same college I went to. My son is
a sophomore at the same college. Everyone has different degrees
of success.
Some people say I'm a cynic. Say I'm brash.
Thelma: Thank you Dennis Tiepelman.
I know you have been a successful leader here. I'm saddened by
some of the testimony here today. This area has always brought
forward great leaders. The education system. I hope we can find
a way to get the students motivated.
_ of tape 2: Get recording:
I went to college and graduated but that doesn't mean I'm any
better than anyone else. Some people think I'm an outsider since
my return. Just because I got As and Bs just means that I could
convince a teacher in a school system that I was worthy. Even
without a degree many people have many worthy skills. I don't
know how to skin an animal as good as Pete does. Going to college
doesn't mean you have the right skills.
Michael Oleksa: Concern about
kids and suicide.
Dennis Tiepelman: shares his
concerns.
Sen. Bettye Davis: Thanks for
testimony. Gives me a lot to think about. My thoughts about vocational
education, as a black parent, was that I didn't want my child
on that track. I was told that the vocational programs were for
the "dumb" kids and I didn't want that. So I think
it has changed since then. We have to find a way to make sure
all kids are equal, whether they go to the college track or the
vocational track to learn a skill.
A. I thought about it the other
way. I was forced into the college track and what I really wanted
to be was a mechanic. I always wanted to be a mechanic.
Fran Ulmer: Thank you so much
for your efforts on the POPS Treaty and contaminants in subsistence
foods.
Rep. Reggie Joule
The tragedy of Sept.
11 has brought together this country to discuss tolerance. It
should be used as an opportunity. Minorities and those of us
in rural Alaska fall under an umbrella. When it comes to programs
we seem to be the last.
I was proud of Anchorage when they came together recently and
said No. Not in our Town. That's the good thing, and therein
lies an opportunity. It caused me to ask the question. When paintballs
were thrown against Alaska Natives where was Not in Our
Town? When murders of Alaska Native women and other minorities
where was Not in Our Town? WE've finally got to that place
and I'm glad but it took a lot to get there. Someone from the
business community and someone who is a good friend of the Mayor.
That's what it took and I'm glad that people have embraced it.
Again, though. Was it because too many of our Alaska Native people
have a problem with alcohol and we get these stereotypes
is that why there isn't the outcry for the discrimination
against us? I address Sen. Davis today because the Senate is
where some of the worst discrimination against one area of the
state is happening today. We have a major fight on our hands
in this upcoming Legislative session. There is an assault on
rural Alaska. Particularly against the North Slope Borough. We
have 60 people who represent many walks of life and many of us
have never been to any other parts of the state and know nothing
about these other areas. We should. The Legislature has many
committees. We don't have session from May to December, so some
of those committees should be meeting in rural Alaska. Some of
it is happening. We thank you for coming here. Taking the time
to learn about our area.
I saw our district court judge
walk in to the meeting and it reminds me of something. Corrections.
We're sending our prisoners all over the place. IT's time for
regional jails. We've tried the private prison route and it's
not working. Regional jails will cost more money but we need
them. We have nothing here to deal with juveniles. No juvenile
justice here in Kotzebue.
Education: In rural Alaska,
in the Hub communities, these are the economic centers. We have
a system in place where we talk about High Stakes and high standards.
With high standards we want students to be challenged by success
and say, yes, we can succeed. High stakes puts a lot of weight
on failure. When the exit exam came out I voted against it. If
you put it in economic terms, there's not much incentive for
students to graduate because they don't feel like it will make
a difference in their village. Is there a way we can create a
system for the villages where we have them job share with people
in the hub communities. Teachers for part of the time in Kotzebue
and then back to their village. Maybe that could be expanded
to state jobs as Troopers and VPSOs. Look at a way to get a career
ladder. A lot of people aren't interested in making $100,000
a year. What we need is employment to be able to live in the
villages and live off the land.
Walter Sampson
Vice President Regional
Affairs, NANA Regional Corporation.
After listening to some of the issues that were talked about.
Some were emotional and some were heartening where you just want
to do something. All of us need a good kick on the behind to
get on the right track. I would like to remind all of us what
occurred in New York on Sept. 11. I think that was a wakeup call
for all of us. I say that because certainly, this nation has
strayed away from its beliefs. I want to thank the Commission
for coming to Kotzebue to listen. I only wish that you would
be able to go to a small community and listen to the real roots
of the problems. It would have been an eye-opener to go to the
village. Something you wouldn't have heard at other hearings.
Living conditions and what it's like. All of us should be happy
that we have an opportunity to share our concerns. To share the
issues that we have to live with every day. For my age group,
I grew up in a whole different environment than we have today.
When I grew up it was the Bureau of Indian Affairs that was responsible
for education. We were told that English would be our language.
Our Inupiaq way was lost. I was one of those children who broke
every rule. I spoke Inupiaq. I was told to make a choice. Walk
out the door or stand in the corner for speaking Inupiaq.
My grandmother was my mentor and my teacher. That's where all
my education started. She was my teacher. When I took the door
my grandmother didn't say anything. The third day, the teacher
came to my house to get me to go to school. I told him that the
choice that I made would be my choice. The 4th day I went back
to school. Being told I could not speak my language was not something
I expected. I didn't know anything about discrimination
I was just told by the federal system. Today it is different.
Communities are trying to become proactive. Both the state and
federal system. But sometimes it's hard to be proactive in those
systems. The state and federal government are used to demanding
things. An example is the State Game Board. I was appointed to
the Board and it was a challenge. I was the only Native in the
whole state. It was a challenge. My first two years I worked
to make a change in the system. That didn't work. So the next
two years, I worked on the process of how we deal with people.
I had some success on that. All these years the Board of Game
meetings were held either in Fairbanks or Anchorage. All the
rural interests had to pay their way to get to the public meetings.
I worked to regionalize the meetings. Even that was a challenge.
When you have a system in place, it is difficult to make a change.
I did have the support and people agreed that the rural communities
are a part of the public process. Rural Alaska is impacted by
these many meetings that take place. Created rural advisory councils.
You have to learn to balance the interests.
Today, our communities are
trying to be proactive. If we are going to work to better our
system. We need to make a change in ourselves. We need to learn
to listen to people. You and I go out to hearings, to meetings,
where people raise issues of concerns. We shelve our notes. Rather
than pointing fingers, we need to ask ourselves what we can do
before it becomes a big problem. Sometimes we pass regulations,
we pass laws, for the people throughout the states. This is the
law, you have to abide by it. If we can't enforce those regulations
and those laws, why even have them on the books. Fish and game
is a good example. Any laws. You better have dollars set aside
to enforce them.
One of the things we all need
to work on. We need to work on the process to make a change.
People at the state level are used to doing things like they
did 20 years ago. My role as a board member was to listen to
the public and adopt regulations based on what I heard. And I
got flack for that. But I don't care. What you are doing is the
same. I encourage you to go to the smaller communities and thank
you for what you are doing.
William Sheldon (Billy Sheldon
Jr.)
I am originally from
Noorvik. When the federal government had BIA schooling, things
were a lot better. The State has failed us. Life has eroded in
the villages. The villages need jobs. I think this is a wake
up call. If you don't heed the call the feds will come in. The
Self-determination act. These IRAs are recognized. Even our corrections
system. How can that be fair. I'm jumping from one thing to another.
Communication is the problem.
John Schaeffer, NANA Regional
Elders Council (member of the 1992-94 federal/state Alaska Natives
Commission)
Of all the people who
testified today, I'm the only historian in the group except
for Willie. When Thelma (Tolerance Commission member Thelma Buchholdt)
first came up here, I was involved in trying to put together
an aboriginal organization. We hired Thelma and her husband to
come up here. I have also worked with Fran (Ulmer, lt. Governor)
and Marie (Greene, Commission member from Kotzebue now
Vice President of NANA). In 1981, Marie and I were looking at
the 10 year anniversary of the Native Claims Settlement Act and
what problems we had in our region. We were both young and didn't
know very much. We had sense enough to talk to our elders and
use the information they gave us. We came up with a list of Inupiaq
values, which have been adopted by the tribes with very few changes.
We used them as part of a community wellness. The teachers and
schools adopted the values. Since then, we have seen less and
less use of the values. In schools we can have some discussion
of culture as part of language. So we started Inupiaq day, where
we get the elders to come in and teach some of our values. And
we tried to get it one day each month of the nine months of the
school year. WE got five days. Now, we've got three days. Worked
on state/federal Natives Commission board and came up with a
report. We had three things.
Dependence on Government. That has created most of the problem
we have with our feeling of not being in charge of our life.
You, as a state commission, Sometimes I think the Robin Taylor's
of the world have a point in cutting us off. If you cut us off,
then we'd have to do things differently. We wouldn't be as healthy.
We wouldn't have certain things, but we'd be doing things for
ourselves. I'm not saying I want that, necessarily, but we do
need to do things for ourselves.
Walter Sampson said it best we've got a band-aid system.
See the problem and try to fix it. All over the U.S., Native
people are struggling. The past. Our culture was taken over by
a different system, a different way of life. Alcohol. When we
didn't have any money we couldn't afford booze. Mistreatment
of women. Learned that from drunken parties where the smallest
people get taken advantage of. Individuals are treated in a band-aid
system and sent back to the problem. That may work in the western
system where you are only connected to a smaller family. We have
a huge extended family. We need more of a wholistic program to
deal with the alcoholism and its aftereffects. Sexual abuse counseling
is important on an individual basis but again, our small communities
with extended families where everyone knows everyone we
need community healing.
Recommendations of commission. Sen. Stevens and Sen. Inouye worked
to provide funding for our recommendations and first it went
to AFN. It took us a few years, but we learned that AFN isn't
the right organization. We need the regional healthcare organizations
in our case, Maniilaq, to address these issues of wholistic
wellness. Once the families can heal then the children will be
able to go to school and learn. We'll have people who are in
control of what's going on. Unless we deal with our dysfunction,
we'll never get anywhere. Education is the key. Once we get started,
it's not going to be that hard. It's going to be easy. We did
it, Marie. I should have left it to Marie because I was still
a drunk at the time. Marie wasn't. Back then we didn't have too
many women in charge. Now we know women are running the show.
(middle of the tape) When I
grew up, the white men in charge were more respectful. They were
more tolerant. As time goes on, children of the people who populate
southcentral Alaska. Children of military retirees and others,
who pass their ignorance onto their children. I see our Legislature
doing the same thing. Thinly veiled racism in our Legislature,
attacking rural Alaska. Everyone knows they aren't attacking
the white people who live in the rural areas. They are attacking
us natives.
Walter Sampson talked a little
bit about the Game Board. Community involvement.
Need to be intolerant of people like that. Needs to start at
the top. The Governor, with his appointments to the game board.
Shari: Heard a lot about how
wellness is a priority, but yet everyone in a community knows
who the bootleggers are, and yet they don't turn them in. What
is that about?
A. Losing control. When we try to take control, what happens?
They turn in someone for bootlegging and what happens. They get
pulled away to testify against someone, and then they go back
to the community with no police protection. It's not safe. We
had a discussion about this with our elders. One elder did get
the courage to tell a young bootlegger, I know what your doing.
Stop it and get out. And the guy did stop. And we were proud
of the elder because what he could have done is shot him or beat
him up. These villages don't have protection. The system doesn't
fit us. When we do have police, we get a few arrests for drunk
and disorderly, and then we go to jail. Go to jail for a long
time, and that leaves a hole in our community. With fewer people,
each person has a function. When that person is gone that service
is gone.
The way we are looking now
is the spirit camp alternative to treat the whole family.
Question: Did you feel the
recommendations of the federal state report you produced were
followed through in any way? We didn't have any expectations
about what the state would do. The federal recommendations we
figured they would have to pursue because of the federal Indian
Rights issues. And it took a long time, but finally Sen. Stevens
has committed to funding some of the projects. I encourage you
to dust off the state recommendations in your work to find tolerance.
I thank you for your work.
I wish you better luck with your report so that it doesn't gather
dust on the shelf.
Richard Erlich, District
Court Judge
My comments do not
represent the court system. Chief Justice Dana Fabe is the head
of the court system. The Governor is head of the Executive Branch
of government. It's important to recognize that the police, district
attorney, corrections, public defenders, etc. all work for the
Executive branch of the government.
Three stories that go to the issue of state. My wife is Inupiaq.
When we were married people thought she was Vietnamese. She grew
up in Nome. When she was young she couldn't go to the movies.
Her father and others changed that. Seven years ago my wife and
I were in Anchorage to buy a table. It was a nice table and flattened
out big enough for a large family. I mentioned they should sell
them in the villages or in rural Alaska. He responded in with
derogatory comments about my wife. Her culture. It was humiliating,
and it was hate. I asked for and got an apology from the owner
of that company. I had to write them more than once. I had to
write the letter as a lawyer would write the letter. Not everyone
has the ability to do that.
Subsistence: A way for people
to keep their identity. The more we interfere and prevent that,
the more we are responsible for contributing to the death of
a people. Not a culture, a people.
I passed out some materials.
It's important to know about this region. Here, almost 85 percent
of the people were born, raised and live here. Whole bunch of
interrelationships we never experience in the urban area. Different
dynamic here than in urban areas. Your credibility here comes
from your length of stay, and whether people trust you or not.
Doesn't matter who the police, or correctional officers, or district
attorneys are. They are leaving in two or three years however
long they have to stay here.
People of the western world
don't understand the value of people to their community. For
example, the person responsible for our heat in our court system
was arrested and had to go to prison. We had to call him to find
out how to fix it.
A number of people have testified
that it's too bad that you didn't get to a village. And that's
too bad, because you can't see the atrocious conditions of a
village jail. It is a holding cell. You wouldn't believe it.
You've all heard of the Cleary lawsuit, which relates to overcrowding
in prisons. That lawsuit doesn't deal with contract jails. Here
in Kotzebue we have a 12-bed contract jail. Often there are 18
to 20 people there. Cots have been set up.We are taking advantage
of a people and a culture, and then we are hammering them again.
Don't give them the respect.
Legislature: They have imposed
laws which require certified kinds of things. They want sex offender
training certified by Corrections. For Batterer prevention they
want certified trainers from the AK Council on Domestic Violence
and Sexual Assault. I know for Nome, Kotzebue and Barrow, there
are no certified counselors. The Batterer and Sexual Assault
Law requires the certified person and doesn't allow other types
of training to get around it. They need to remember that urban
and rural life is different.
40 percent of our population is under 18. That is a tremendous
amount. We are about 1.5 adults per child. Statewide it's about
2. something and nationwide it's 3 times. We have families. We
have more single-father headed households. Our median age is
23.9. That means John Shaeffer isn't a relic, he's a treasure.
John said the joint federal/state
commission the state didn't do anything. I think the court
did hear some of the recommendations. We have a new magistrate
here who is attempting to make a community court work here without
any lawyers. I need to thank Gov. Knowles and Gen. Oates, who,
even though everything is busy right now, approved the use of
the Armory in Selawik. Speaks to the court's commitment, administration's
commitment to make something work.
Mara Kimmel: Do you have the
need for interpreters here? Yes. Inupiaq and Korean and Village
English and sign language. Sometimes we need them and it has
been a problem. Thelma Buchholdt and I were part of a subcommittee
on the court's fairness and access task force and we were successful
in convincing the courts they needed to have them. The courts
will now have to pay for translators in criminal court cases.
Would certified interpreter programs work? Yes, if we can access
them by phone.
Alcohol problem in our state.
What do you see as a solution?
You have to understand that 60 percent of the people nationwide
who are in jail, were under the influence of drugs or alcohol.
It's a nationwide problem. We have tobacco lawsuits today. The
interrelation of things needs to be understood. We as a society
do not address the relationships. Since the change in the Child
in Need of Aid law, we are finally starting to look at those
issues. Alcohol problems are part of violence in the family and
leads to sexual assault and other problems.
Shari Kochman story about racism
toward the jewish community. Jewwing you down, and other racial
stereotypes in an interaction with a business. Her friend also
had to write repeated letters to highlight the issue and get
an apology. Everyone in the company except for the person making
the derogatory comment signed the apology.
The personal humiliation people
go through and you don't want to go through that. I'm in a position
to deal with that and I have the skills, but what about the person
who doesn't.
Michael Oleksa comments on
how the Tolerance Commission has had dissatisfaction with the
fact that the Commission's budget didn't allow for smaller communities.
Lincoln Saito, Director,
UAF Chukchi Campus, Kotzebue
I've been an educator
in the state for 32 years. Right now I'm the director for the
Chukchi Campus. I've lived in Wrangell. I taught at Mt. Edgecumbe
in Sitka. I lived in Fairbanks for 8 years. Was a principal in
Homer and Kwethluk and now I'm here. One of the things I'd like
to recommend is boarding schools in Bush areas. One of the things
that happens when I go back to Homer, Anchorage, Fairbanks is
that people don't look at me. They think I'm Alaska Native. I
wouldn't have noticed it but I have lived in rural Alaska
for many years, and I notice it when I go back. People don't
recognize you as a human. Rural schools could help. If we had
a boarding school here in Kotzebue, it would make a difference.
Kotzebue has natives running things. Just think about it, if
no one looks at you in school. It affects even me, an older person.
But if I were in High School or college and no one looked at
me? It's terrible. I think you would see less of a drop-out rate
if you had a Native-run boarding school. I've been learning from
my environment for a long time.
Mary Kapsner. I traveled with
an educational group last year and we examined the idea of regional
boarding schools that would follow career tracks. A health care
or mechanical program. Former speaker of the House Gail Phillips
was championing that, and since her retirement, there hasn't
been much follow-though. There is a report out I can send you.
We aren't saying we will eliminate Molly-Hootch schools, but
supplementing them.
Lincoln Saito:
Noticed as he was grading papers from his correspondence courses
that the Native students who didn't come to Fairbanks were all
passing college classes but not the ones who went to Fairbanks.
Meeting wrap up. Next public
hearings in Soldotna October 22 and Anchorage during AFN October
23, noon to 4 p.m. at the Egan Convention Center.
Post a Comment --------View Comments-----Submit an Opinion - Letter
Sitnews
Stories In The News
|