Tolerance Commission Public
Hearing
September 29, 2001 - Anchorage,
Alaska
Fairview Recreation Center, 10 a.m. to 1 p.m.
Please note that these are
not the official minutes of the meeting. These are quickly typed-in
notes provided by staff. Audio tapes will be available for purchase
by the public at IMIG Audio/Video, 2611 Fairbanks St. Suite 100,
Anchorage, AK 99503. Please contact Zena at (907) 274-2161. The
price is $6 per 120 minute tape.
Introduction of Commission Members:
Mara Kimmel of Anchorage
Denise Morris of Anchorage
Kelly Brown of Fairbanks
Judge Tom Stewart of Juneau
Sen. Bettye Davis, Chair (Rev. Chuck Eddy had family emergency)
Gilbert Sanchez of Anchorage
Marie Greene of Kotzebue
Sen. Georgianna Lincoln of Rampart
Thelma Buchholdt of Anchorage
Shari Kochman of Juneau
Rep. Mary Kapsner of Bethel
Rev. Michael Oleksa of Koliganek
Channel 2 News Coverage
Geoff Kennedy, APRN
Testimony
Sen. Johnny Ellis, represents
Fairview and Mountain View in Alaska Senate
Awesome array of talent
in this room. Commend Gov. and Lt. Governor for recognizing the
problems we have. Fairview and Mountain View. I'm sure you will
hear some interesting and disturbing stories. Hopefully it will
get to other members of the Legislature. I hope it's ignorance
and not hate.
David Sam
Child of Kagwonton.
And that's how I come to you today. I wrote David Sam because
that's the word in English. Difficult to articulate because I've
been taught by white people. To stand here before you is very
hard because it raises questions about who am I. Because it wasn't
taught to me in school. My little brother remembers walking into
kindergarten in my mother's hand. As soon as she left he begins
to cry. He thought, I'm being given away. And it's so true. Nothing
in the school district paid any attention at all as to who we
are as a people. And that continues today. The white male system
consistently kills messengers. The anger and the rage sometimes
comes out. The messages aren't heard. I have a three year old
granddaughter. At a gathering last Friday after another act of
terrorism it was too big to understand. Maybe my daughter
will be able to articulate what has happened to U.S. when she
gets older. But this act of terrorism has been consistent to
indigenous people. I lived in Sitka. We need to pay attention
to what happens to our young people. My granddaughter has a right
to learn who she is. White male system makes the indigenous people
invisible. I don't know what's worse. Walking into a school and
being given away or suicide, which is how our young people has
dealt with these issues. I give thanks to Father Oleksa at the
subsistence hearings to open the door. But no disrespect
why do you kill the messenger and not listen to the message.
I appreciate the work that has been done by Father Oleksa with
cross-cultural training and InterCambios with bilingual programs.
No Native people at masses that took place last week after the
terrorist attacks. The damage that has been done to our people
is great. A book I encourage you to read. Native American Post
Colonial psychology, by Eduardo and Bonnie Duran. It talks about
depression. I'm sure you've been hearing many different perspectives
about the damage. The system is working against us. Please, continue
to listen and stay involved. Listen to the young people. It'd
be good if you could do this same thing in the middle of the
schools. I'm tired of our children being taken away by the Division
of Family and Youth Services and in the school system. Thank
you.
Questions from Denise Morris,
Shari Kochman. Sen. Davis encourages Mr. Sam to participate in
school activities today.
Suggestions:
Encourage more culturally-competent instruction. Curriculum developed
by indigenous people. Include Indigenous males so children will
have role models. I was director of the Sitka Native education
program. The program was extra it wasn't part of the regular
school program.
Gloria Sasieta
Concern is minority
kids in the school district. It's sad to see how race and color
and background makes you go through steps where they will bring
you down no matter what. I'm not black. I'm Hispanic from south
America. I had to learn the language and it was hard. Raised
in New Jersey and it was hard there and really tough here. I
have one kid who was kicked out of the school system and he can't
go back. My kid has been out of school since April. I have gone
to meetings and no one calls me back. No one can help me. Nobody
listens. He has a police record now because of threats. How does
kicking kids out of school help your child. I know it is happening
to others and I don't understand why they don't come forward.
I need help to get his education back. If a kid has a disability
you still have to help them. I have left my name over and over.
You have probably heard my name before.
Bettye Davis and Gloria conversation.
I understand your son was expelled (Hanshew middle school). What
are you now doing for your son? I have applied for home schooling.
Sen. Davis: Didn't you receive a letter from the school district
telling you how to get him back into school? I want the school
district to remove the statement that one teacher says he said.
No other students heard the comment he "allegedly"
said. I want them to investigate more and have the comment taken
off. It's a big thing for a 13 year old to go through. Sen. Davis:
I agree something needs to be done. Your child needs to go to
school. You have to realize that there are certain things you
are going to have to do. Please get with someone other than the
school district to walk you through the process. Goal for Gloria:
Get his records cleared. My son wants to go to school. He's getting
counseling and wants to go back.
Sen. Lincoln and Gilbert Sanchez
questions: Thank you for having the courage to come and testify.
Gilbert:
Lynne Koral
I live in the Fairview
area. Alaska Independent Blind Convention. I was so glad it was
close. I had asked if there had people with disabilities testifying
and was told that there haven't been too many people. Having
tolerance in our community should be the same as having inclusion
in our community. Summary of meeting that I read on the web site.
People talk about employers. Well, people in the disability community
are told they can't get jobs. Access is difficult. Many times,
people don't go out of their house. They are afraid and don't
have the training. It's up to us to educate people on our needs.
Braille needs to be in the school district. We can be employed
if we have the right equipment. Assistive technology is needed.
Funding is needed. Anyone of you could become disabled at any
time. Anyone of you could have a family member with a disability.
The isolation, depression. Some of us with disabilities have
families who feel like they were failures so they don't embrace
their family members with disabilities. Lot of alcohol abuse
with the vision impaired and blind community because there is
so much pain. I love every human being and it is hard to listen
to people who think we are complaining. We are just letting people
know our needs. We want to be integrated into society. Disability
crosses all lines. All races, all classes, all cultures. We can't
just put our heads in the sand and forget about it.
(Most lines are attitudinal not architectural Shari Kochman
asks if she can use this quote from Lynne to put in our report).
Do you think all blind people should be integrated into the
You have to take the individual into account. Integration is
best most of the time. We are already separated by the barriers
in society. I don't think people mean to be against people with
disabilities. We target ourselves a lot of times and it is difficult
for us.
Alaska Information Rehabilitation
Services (AIRS): This is where you can get Braille done. Not
as many places as there used to be. Radio reader services and
other 907 563-2120
Sen. Lincoln thanks Lynne for
reminding us that we need to be more aware of how much more difficult
it is to get around when you have disabilities.
Sandra Anderson
I'd like to thank Sen.
Ellis. He's the reason I'm here today because he sent me an email.
Thanks Sen. Ellis. Teacher at High School in Anchorage. I teach
ESL. 500 students in the School district. English as a Second
Language. 4 bilingual interpreters at my school. I'm here to
talk about the High School Exit Exams. We are having the test
next weeks. I proctored that exam last year and it was difficult
to watch them struggling. My students are immigrants and the
language is difficult. My students did better on the math portion
but didn't do as well on the English portion. They realized as
they were doing the exam that they didn't have the language skills.
Many of my students have children already. Some are in early
20s. Sole providers for their family. Many of my students have
jobs. Go to school from 7:30 to 2:30 and then go to a full work
day. Many students feel like why bothering because they don't
think they will pass. You have to know poetry and language and
history from this American culture that they just didn't have
time to learn yet. I see it as elitist and possibly even racist.
These people are intelligent but they just haven't acquired the
language skills yet. I would like to see the exam as optional.
It could be on their record that they took it or not. But if
they take the required courses to pass, they should get a diploma.
You probably won't hear too many voices on this because
Denise Morris and Thelma Buchholdt
questions and comments.
Alice Sam
I have a Down's Syndrome
daughter who is 29 and I see so many people who treat her so
terrible. It hurts me to this day. She didn't ask to be brought
into this world. She's now in Juneau at REACH. She's working
two jobs. She is doing good. I am terrified to speak. I saw
how lonely the retarded children are. My daughter cries. I grew
up with prejudice because my father was Japanese. I was an emotional
child. I was 8 or 9 years old when they took my father. I heard
from my family don't forget you are Japanese. Prejudice
is really hurtful. You don't know unless you go through it. Thank
you. I'm not a speaker but Georgianna asked me to speak so I
did.
Sen. Lincoln: Comments on how
difficult it is to come up and speak. Thanks Alice and encourages
others to have the courage to tell the commission how you feel.
Juliette Hildreth
Live in Anchorage,
relocated after spending some time in village but moved to Anchorage
because there wasn't economic opportunity. I want to give you
the perspective to be a baby ANCSA. So much disrespect for shareholders
of corporate and tribal leadership. I want to tell you there
is reverse racism in the Native community. I don't want to speak
too harshly because some of the people are in my own family.
Everyone is too busy, driving their cars and using their cell
phones. I got Sen. Davis on the phone, my legislator, but I can't
get a hold of Native people in my corporation. There is a rift
between the young and older shareholders. The disrespect I get
you can hear it in my voice. I'm just a halfbreed. Bigotry.
A pipeline company section 29 recruit, train and
retain. Joint pipeline federal state office. EEO officer never
enforced the clause. My Native corporation never fought for the
jobs. It landed with AFN and they had me go over to Alyeska pipeline.
I know what has happened to my application. It has been thrown
away four times. Yet retired AFN employees are on the payroll.
Young natives don't have a chance. There is a groundswell of
shareholders who are getting so disenfranchised. When I read
about this today. Another report on racial discrimination. It
gets so tiring. One person can make a difference. I've gone through
five section 29 managers. How difficult can it bge. Recruit,
train and retain. People saying they are culturally diverse because
they have "black" friend. That makes me sick. It's
a big mess out there. I have some big mentors. Roger Cremo. He
keeps moving forward. There is a very unhappy Native community.
I won't let my kids go to AFN. I tell my kids don't drink,
don't smoke. They go there and that's what they do. Sen. Davis
thank you for always being there when we have problems
in our district.
Rep. Mary Kapsner question:
What is your corporation? It's mixed because the elders are dying.
I have a mix. Management calls you a dissident for saying anything.
Shareholders have a big problem. Internal strife within the regional
corporations. Native appointees to the Governor's office were
all over 50 and were all men. The Native Liaisons. I spoke to
Tim Twardock, one of the Native liaisons about the concept of
having a representation of the Native Community, he just didn't
understand the concept.
Sen. Davis:
Don't give up on your people. Continue to have your voice be
heard but know that not everyone can agree on everything.
Regina Manteufel
I've been active in
the Fairview community for 12 years. I've been active at this
center for longer than that. I'm hear to talk to you about problems
with Parks and Recreation. We are not having a mix of students
like we should. Should have the Hillside kids mixing with our
Fairview kids. Mix the blind students and the overweight kids
and girls and different cultures like the Native events.
We don't have that. We have traditional white sports. I have
been raising funds for this center. I keep bringing up ideas
for this center to do to raise money and they don't do it. We
have cuts to the Parks and Rec budget and funds from this center
being diverted all over town. Why don't we have a big camping
trip over here at this park Lyons park. We busted our butt
to get it. We can get volunteers for International events but
no one to help out with events locally. There aren't enough girls
on these sports teams. It gets so frustrating. I've had 12 years
of fighting with the staff trying to get people to do things.
I'm getting ready to take out a $1000 ad to let people know what's
going on. These kids are missing out. I was lucky because my
mom got me involved in things young. I've been a victim of a
hate crime. I was beat up when I was a kid because I was white.
I've been raped. I've seen little girls get together and form
a team but no one works with them. I have people call me and
ask me to help set things up. People have these lists but people
don't want to share them. Would it be too difficult to send an
email to 200 people asking them if they would volunteer to set
up a camping trip at the park. I'm tired of baseball. Why can't
we have a camping trip?
Andrea McCloud
Three things I want
to talk about. 1.) Definition of Tolerance to add to record from
webster's dictionary. Sympathy or indulgence for beliefs that
are different or conflicting from one's own. It is intimidating
to speak in front of bodies such as yours. I have done it before
but it is always intimidating. I was watching the news last night
and that's what brought me here. Something was said that I'm
concerned with and that's why I had to speak up today. Saying
them: and Us. I was showed a lot of intolerance by a member of
your commission. I was not tolerated. Look at yourselves and
see how tolerant you are. This isn't them or us it's that we
have different beliefs.
2.) Human Rights Commission. Back in '82 I brought up systemic
discrimination. The Human Rights Commission has a stamp that
says "there is no substantial proof of discrimination"
They need to get rid of that stamp. Food stamp program. They
found discrimination and it had to come back to the State.
3.) Speaking English. I'm an immigrant from the Middle East and
I didn't speak English until I was 8 years old. I think the English
and Second Language only programs inhibit people. I work in the
School District and those programs are a dumping ground. Look
into that.
Under the Human Rights Commission should expand its list of protected
classes. Add political beliefs. If you are not part of a certain
party you are not listened to. Divisive between the Democrats
and Republicans. I'm a non-partisan. There are a lot of non-partisans
out there. I was in the elevator with one of you and asked about
a governor's veto and
Theresa Obermeyer
Gender equity. Women
are minorities. Referred to the agenda from yesterday's Tolerance
Commission meeting and said it wasn't advertised. Upset because
she would have come if she had known about it. Everything is
a paper shuffle in this state. One of my jokes is "all I
have in life is a 34-cent postage stamp." I have three teenagers
at East High. I am being prosecuted by my children's principal
again. A police officer came to my door yesterday. It's all so
ridiculous. My son's final football game is happening and I can't
go to it. I'm really lucky. I've always been helped. I've always
been believed. I was surprised when I came here. 17 years of
Hate Crimes against the Obermeyer family. The greatness of the
United States of America is individual responsibility. I have
tried too long. You are being used. Refers to the list of speakers
at yesterday's meeting. Carol Comeau. She just sent me a certified
letter. 6 fabricated court trials I have been called to. What
about my family. All of this is so sick and demented. It's an
effort to tear my marriage apart. My father was a judge: He always
told me the greatest thing in life is a good story. I have lots
of good stories. Politicians in DC. Main job is getting their
children elected to the State Legislature. I'm sorry Rev. Eddy
isn't here today. I hear he has a family emergency. High School
exit exam. That is Exxon.
Shirley Saucelman
I'm a physician in
Anchorage. Praise a couple good things I've seen in Anchorage
recently. Judge Rose's mental health court. Treat people's illness
rather than through the jail. This is a very serious time for
persons with mental illness. National Alliance for Mentally Ill.
Sadly, family of people of mental illness are forced to deal
with criminal justice. Hope to have brain treated as part of
the body. Things are getting a little better. We do have medications
so people can live in their community. New CIT Crisis Intervention
Team. The Mental Health Trust John Malone is very
interested in it. Gets people into treatment, even before they
are tried with a crime. This is worse for someone with darker
skin. They tend to get less treatment and go to jail longer.
Question from Shari Kochman:
How do we get a CIT Crisis Center here? How would it be funded?
Sam Cochran of the national one is wonderful. Is there a similar
crisis intervention program for alcohol? She doesn't know.
Debbie Hunter
I didn't think I was
going to get called here. Listening to political testimony. This
happens to be racial. I was crossing the street the other day.
I had the Right of Way. I was walking and the car stopped. So
I continued walking. She stopped again. So I stepped back and
what I think she was trying to do is hit me. She did. She was
white. Hit me directly. I was screaming so loudly some people
who were at 5th Avenue Mall came over. They didn't see the accident.
She claimed it was an accident. The police officer believed her.
He was also white. I started yelling because I thought he was
taking her side. I have had serious back problems. The paramedics
told me I needed to calm down. The officer told me she was being
charged with failure to yield to a pedestrian in a crosswalk.
She was also driving without a license. That wasn't the first
time I was targeted by a white motorist. The day before. Same
thing, I had the Right of Way. Ford Bronco. He saw me in the
crosswalk. It was like he was playing chicken with me. Daring
me to walk across the street. Several incidents prior to that,
both involved white male motorists. First I went to Channel 13.
White male reporter said, "what's the point here. What's
the story here." "What would you be trying to accomplish
for putting this in the news." Apparently there was an anonymous
caller who reported the incident and also for public safety purposes
I think it is important. He didn't think public safety issues
were important. I went to Channel 11. I specifically wanted to
speak to Mary Case because she was Korean. She said, "we
don't do old stories." She made some remark about people
being stalked or something. All these excuses for not being able
to put this in the news. There could have been someone who had
seen it. This is the news media here that doesn't think safety
is in issue. I realize they can't put every little fender-bender
in the news. I know that. This time I'm knocked off my feet on
my back. And this isn't significant enough to be in the news?
What if it had been reverse? If a white woman was hit by a black
person or Native person. They'd put that in the news and be tracking
it down. It's the media's responsibility to inform the public.
Someone from the audience asks
if she tried to write a letter to the editor. She hasn't yet
but she's been notifying the business community.
Rep. Kapsner offers her sympathy
for her having to go through this. Gilbert Sanchez urges her
to notify others in the community.
Other business:
Rep. Mary Kapsner reads a legislative citation sponsored by her
honoring Father Michael Oleksa for his years of work strengthening
communication between Alaskans. Father Michael has lived and
worked in rural Alaska for many years and speaks Yup'ik. He created
a cross-training cultural series of tapes and does training statewide.
Post a Comment --------View Comments-----Submit an Opinion - Letter
Sitnews
Stories In The News
|